Your offer has been accepted. Congratulations! Now it’s time to work through your conditions, including arranging your financing.
Your bank or mortgage broker will need a copy of the Agreement of Purchase and Sale—the formal name for the contract we usually call “the offer.” From there, your application goes through several approval steps behind the scenes.
One of those steps may be a formal property appraisal. The lender wants to make sure the property provides adequate security value for the mortgage. That helps protect it from lending too much, whether the purchase price reflects an enthusiastic buyer, a bidding war, or outright fraud.
An appraiser has specialized training in assessing real estate value and must meet the lender’s requirements. Lenders commonly select from their own particular approved appraisers or appraisal companies.
The appraiser considers the property and relevant market evidence, including comparable sales, making adjustments for differences such as size, condition, location, and features. They don’t “set” the market value so much as provide an independent opinion of what the property is worth based on real world evidence.
As a buyer, you’re probably less concerned with the calculations than with the result: does the appraisal support the price you agreed to pay?
If it comes in low, you could have a financing gap.
Suppose you agree to pay $700,000, but the lender accepts an appraised value of only $550,000. It will generally calculate its maximum mortgage using that lower value, subject to its lending requirements and your financial qualifications.
If the lender will advance 80% of $550,000, that means a $440,000 mortgage. You would need to provide the remaining $260,000 yourself, plus closing costs. That’s the $150,000 difference between the purchase price and appraised value, plus a $110,000 down payment on the appraised value.
Your required down payment increased by $120,000 from the $140,000 you were planning. That can be an unpleasant surprise—especially if you stretched yourself on your offer to win a bidding war and left out the financing condition.
A mortgage pre-approval doesn’t eliminate this risk. The lender still needs to approve the particular property and purchase. Without a financing condition, or after you’ve waived it, you may be contractually committed even if the expected mortgage doesn’t materialize. Failing to close could put your deposit at risk and expose you to a claim for additional damages.
So, can you challenge a low appraisal?
You can ask your lender or mortgage broker about a review, particularly if there are factual errors or relevant comparable sales that may have been overlooked. But getting the value revised isn’t guaranteed.
Appraisal involves professional judgment, so another lender’s appraisal might produce a different result. Exploring another lender may be an option, but it takes time, may involve additional costs, and offers no assurance of a better outcome. With a closing date approaching, that can mean considerable stress and scrambling.
My advice: whenever possible, include a financing condition and confirm satisfactory financing for the specific property before removing it. If you choose to buy without one, make sure you understand the risk and have the resources to cover a potentially substantial shortfall.